Base:
1 1/2 cups warm water
2 tsp yeast
2 cups bread flour
1 tsp sugar
Mix well, cover and set aside for 2 -12 hours (the longer the better) - I sat mine aside overnight for about 14 hours
Next add:
1 cup flour
2 1/2 tsp salt
Mix well and set aside for 30 minutes
Heat griddle over med. heat for several minutes (add a smidge of butter if non stick)
Place muffin rings on hot griddle and fill 2/3 with batter
Cook on the first side for 5 minutes until bubbles come through and bottom is slightly browned
Flip and cook about 2 minutes, then remove the ring and finish cooking until browned.
Doesn't this sound simple? It was! I will not say I made a perfect batch, but they were tasty.
The problems I did have:
1. I had no muffin rings or cookie cutters to use to shape the muffins, so.....before I let the final dough rise, I used a sprouting jar lid and shaped the batter into circles and let rise that way.
2. I didn't have corn meal to use when shaping up the muffins, so they had a little flour on the outside as opposed to a corn meal dusting
3. I am crazy about things not cooking enough or being well done so I pushed down my english muffins while they were cooking and made them too flat ( I do the same thing with pancakes, I have to stop!)
But despite these issues, they had great holes and crannies, they had that English Muffiny taste and they were a big hit with my family. My sister came over to try one ( she only lives a block away so she can travel easily for food) and ate hers on the way home with no butter, jam, etc and said it was great! I know this isn't a recipe chock full of health, but it's definitely still better for you than the ones bought from the store and it really is that easy!